how to evaluate a digital marketing agency

How to Evaluate a Digital Marketing Agency

If you are in the market to hire a digital marketing agency in Canada, it is essential to have a set of criteria to evaluate the different agencies on your shortlist. As one of the top digital marketing agencies serving smaller businesses, we want to provide you with these insights on selecting the right company for your specific marketing needs. 

Choosing the right digital marketing agency can be a game changer, especially for smaller businesses. Experts in digital marketing for small businesses know how to close gaps in current marketing activities, gain traction, and show measurable results. Bring a whole team of experts for the cost of one employee. Bring focus, discipline, and accountability, along with additional capacity to get marketing work done. They make every marketing dollar count.

Before you entrust an agency with responsibilities like overseeing your advertising campaigns, crafting content, and managing marketing budgets, it’s important to conduct a comprehensive evaluation to ensure they can meet the demands and standards of your business.

Take a look at our top advice when evaluating digital marketing agencies.

Understanding the Role of a Digital Marketing Agency

To start, you’ll need to understand what a digital marketing agency does and how it can revolutionize your marketing strategy. A well-rounded agency should offer a full suite of services, from SEO to social media management, and provide a holistic approach to improving your online presence.

A digital marketing agency is more than just a service provider; it’s a growth catalyst for small and medium-sized businesses to thrive in an online ecosystem. An agile agency has expertise across various digital marketing pillars, including search engine optimization (SEO), pay-per-click (PPC) advertising, content marketing, social media management, email marketing, and conversion rate optimization.

They must also adapt to the constant changes in digital marketing, employing the latest methodologies and forward-thinking strategies. A top-tier agency will help your brand forge meaningful connections with your audience, interpret analytics for strategic adjustments, and generate returns on your marketing investments.

How to Evaluate a Digital Marketing Agency

When it’s time to amplify your business’s digital presence, choosing the right marketing partner becomes a strategic imperative. Here’s how to cut through the clutter and systematically evaluate a full-service digital marketing agency to ensure you find the ideal fit for your company’s needs.

Reputable & Trustworthy

When selecting a digital marketing agency, look for signs of their commitment to industry excellence and continuous learning. Credible agencies may not always have formal accreditations but will demonstrate expertise through thought leadership, such as industry publications or contributions to professional forums.

Assess the agency’s reputation through its engagement with the marketing community, client testimonials, and case studies. A trustworthy agency maintains transparent communication and has a track record of ethical business practices, positioning themselves as strategic partners in your business’s growth rather than mere service providers.

Assessing an Agency’s Track Record

Most digital marketing agencies publish their portfolio online. Review their work before engaging with them in a conversation.

A portfolio will portray the length and breadth of the agency’s work and the challenges solved for various other clients. Portfolios are sometimes supplemented with detailed case studies as well. Case studies follow a problem-solution format and are a good depiction of the projects the digital marketing agency has worked on.

Ask for more detailed case studies during your conversation, explicitly highlighting their content creation abilities (white papers, case studies, infographics, brochures, etc.) and their SEO/SEM and paid advertising abilities.

If the agency has achieved tangible results for another client, it is a good measure of their success and versatility.

Analyzing Communication and Reporting

It is easy for an agency to make broad statements about building a ‘marketing strategy’ and project plan to reach your marketing goals. However, you need a solid idea of how the agency plans to meet those objectives.

A good agency will describe its engagement model right at the start. That model should include the resources it will dedicate to your business, the frequency of interaction with your marketing team, and information about the marketing automation tools they’ll use. Be sure to review their proposals carefully to see if they mesh with your objectives.

And for true success, an agency should treat you as a partner – not just another client. Their team should be assisting your in-house staff on the operation of automated tools and best digital marketing practices along the way, working together to achieve the best outcome.

Similarly, working with your subject matter experts for content creation and promotion should be a seamless process where the agency comes across as an extension of your in-house team rather than another external team that your experts have to adapt to.

A high-performing agency will act as a force multiplier to your marketing efforts. That’s why finding the right fit is so important. 

Evaluating Tools and Technologies

When assessing a digital marketing agency, closely examine the tools and technologies at their disposal. With the marketing landscape constantly evolving, agencies that leverage state-of-the-art resources – including artificial intelligence (AI) – are uniquely positioned to offer innovative solutions that can propel your marketing efforts ahead of the competition.

AI, for example, can revolutionize customer segmentation, personalize customer experiences, optimize campaigns in real-time, and predict future trends. Your chosen agency should possess the tools and the insight needed to utilize them effectively to drive your business objectives.

Considering Agency Culture and Values

Are your company’s values consistent with the culture of your prospective agency? A compatible agency will respect and amplify your brand’s voice while also bringing a perspective that challenges and extends the boundaries of your current marketing paradigm.

A sound agency partnership should be an extension of your in-house team, promoting open communication, mutual respect, and shared goals, which are powerful elements in navigating long-term strategic hurdles and driving sustainable growth.

Decoding Pricing and Value

When it comes to pricing, transparency is needed. A reputable digital marketing agency will provide a clear billing structure while highlighting the value it aims to deliver. It is crucial to compare cost against potential return on investment (ROI), ensuring that your marketing dollars translate into tangible outcomes.

Agencies may offer different pricing models, from retainer-based to project-specific. Understand what each model entails and how it aligns with your objectives and budget. Remember that the cheapest option isn’t always the most cost-effective in the long term. Sometimes, investing in an agency with a proven track record of delivering results can yield a higher ROI.

Digital Marketing Agency

Key Trends Impacting Digital Marketing

Understanding key trends in digital marketing is crucial for selecting an agency capable of navigating current and future landscapes. Here’s a list of relevant key trends to pay attention to:

  • Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning: With AI becoming more sophisticated, agencies must use AI-powered tools for predictive analytics, personalization, and automation.
  • Voice Search Optimization: As more consumers use voice-enabled devices, agencies need to optimize content for voice search to maintain visibility.
  • Video Content and Live Streaming: The growing preference for video content, especially live streams, means agencies must be proficient in engaging audiences through these mediums.
  • Data Privacy and Security: With regulations like GDPR, an agency must be knowledgeable about data privacy laws and ensure compliance with its marketing strategies.
  • Ephemeral Content & Stories: Short-lived content formats like Stories have become a staple in social media strategies, and an agency should have the expertise to leverage this trend.
  • Interactive and Immersive Experiences: Engaging customers through virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR), and interactive content can differentiate a brand in a crowded digital space.
  • Sustainability and Ethical Marketing: As consumers become more environmentally conscious, agencies should incorporate mindful sustainability into marketing campaigns.
  • Influencer Marketing: Leveraging influencers within niche markets can be an effective strategy that agencies should manage with a focus on authenticity and alignment with brand values.

Choosing an agency that can creatively leverage and participate in these trends will ensure your marketing remains relevant and effective.

Set Goals and Refine Objectives

Finally, before you reach out to a digital marketing agency, it’s important to set some tangible, performance-based goals that you’d like to achieve with the help of an agency. If you’re looking to invest in one particular element of your marketing plan – for example, SEO – you would want to hire a digital marketing agency specializing in this area.

In contrast, if you need help building out a full marketing plan, a full-service digital marketing agency would be more suitable.

Your goals should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (or SMART) so you have a clear barometer of progress and success. 

Crafting Your Agency Evaluation Checklist

This handy checklist provides the points you need at a glance to help you select the right digital marketing agency for your business.

1. Digital Marketing Expertise

– Demonstrable experience in SEO, PPC, content marketing, and social media for small businesses
– Knowledge and application of AI and machine learning in marketing strategies
– Strategies for video content creation

2. Cultural Fit

  – Alignment with your company’s values and work style
  – Transparency in communication and collaborative approach

3. Tools and Technology

  – Use of current and advanced marketing tools and analytics platforms
  – Expertise in omnichannel marketing tools and customer relationship management

4. Portfolio and Track Record

  – A varied portfolio showcasing successful campaigns
  – Case studies with tangible results and ROI

5. Communication and Reporting

  – Details on the agency’s engagement model and reporting practices
  – Willingness to educate and integrate their tools with your team

6. Pricing and Value

  – Transparent pricing models and outlined scope of work
  – Cost-effectiveness assessed against potential ROI and added value

7. Understanding of Trends

  – Insight into how current trends can be leveraged for marketing success
  – Proactive approach to adapting strategies based on forecasted economic and digital changes

By reviewing these points with prospective agencies, you can make an informed decision leading to a profitable and sustainable partnership.

Partnering with a Winning Agency

This guide will empower you to effectively communicate the benefits of engaging a digital marketing agency and emphasize the significant impact it can have on your business. These insights will instill confidence in your leadership team when connecting with a marketing agency to steer your company toward a prosperous future.

A capable agency will ensure your marketing initiatives are optimized for performance, resiliency, and alignment with your brand’s core values and objectives – all factors that will help you build a case to your higher-ups for hiring an agency for your marketing needs. 

Now that you know how to evaluate a digital marketing agency, take the next step: reach out to a reputable agency and schedule a consultation. You don’t need to resign yourself to uncertainty when your actions today can secure your company’s future.

Book a free consultation with Asset Digital Communications to find out what we can do for you.

Suggested Reads: